Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Sign in

Structure Dependence, the Rational Learner, and Putnam's "Sane Person"

10/19/2007 1:20 PM Wong Auditorium
Howard Lasnik, PhD '72, Distinguished University Professor, Department of Linguistics, University of Maryland; Juan Uriagereka, Professor, University of Maryland

Description: Young children say many surprising and funny things _ funny, often, because how they say it is not quite right in an endearing way. "My friend goed to the playground," and "I ated two desserts" both demonstrate errors that we readily understand, sympathize with, and are confident will go away with further listening and speaking.

But there are other kinds of errors that children just don't seem to make. In his pathbreaking work on transformational grammar, Noam Chomsky has written extensively about sentences like "The dog in the corner is hungry." By applying a formal operation Chomsky described in detail, we can form the question "Is the dog in the corner hungry?" But confronted with "The dog that is in the corner is hungry," we do not end up asking "Is the dog that in the corner is hungry?" Instead, we apply the transformational rule in a different, more complex way, to ask "Is the dog that is in the corner hungry?"

Chomsky draws two conclusions from close study of many such cases. First, he says, this shows that the transformational grammar rules we follow are "structure"dependent," that is, they apply to phrases, not simply to a string of words in sequence. Second, because a person can go through life without recognizing or even encountering some structure"dependent cases _ and yet make the correct choice when presented with alternatives _ this aspect of grammar has deep implications for human psychology. In fact, Chomsky claims, this is an argument for the existence of invariant principles of language, a universal grammar.

Howard Lasnik cites evidence for a different interpretation: Chomsky's "poverty of the stimulus" scenario may not be relevant. By examining a large collection of speech (drawn from the CHILDES database), and applying a Bayesian model of grammar induction _ making use, in other words, of the speaker's knowledge of prior probabilities _ it is possible to show that a rational learner could in fact learn that transformational linguistic rules depend on phase structure.

Lasnik's former student, now colleague, Juan Uriagereka, broadens the argument. Drawing on a startling range of examples _ from animal behavior to protein folding, Uriagereka wonders if the structural properties of grammar are unique to human language, or extend to other forms of human cognition, including music, mathematics, and complex planning. Structure dependence may be true, it may be specific to language or at least to human thought but how did it get there? Where does structure come from? These are the bold questions Lasnik and Uriagereka believe that contemporary linguistic cognitive science has to address.

About the Speaker(s): Howard Lasnik is the author of A Course in Minimalist Syntax(2005), with Juan Uriagereka, and of Minimalist Investigations in Linguistic Theory (2003). He previously taught at the University of Connecticut, and has been a Fellow of the Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences. He is also a Fellow of the Linguistic Society of America.

Lasnik received his M.A. In English at Harvard University in 1969, and his Ph.D. in Linguistics at MIT in 1972.

Juan Uriagereka is author of Rhyme and Reason; and co"author of A course in GB Syntax: Lectures on Binding and Empty Categories; and editor of Derivations: Exploring the Dynamics of Syntax.

He previously taught as a Visiting Professor at Konstanz University in Germany, and at Wolfson College, Oxford University. He has served as a Visiting Chair, Basque Philology, University of the Basque Country.

Uriagereka received his Ph.D. in Linguistics from the University of Connecticut.

Host(s): School of Engineering, Laboratory for Information and Decision Systems

Comments (0)

It looks like no one has posted a comment yet. You can be the first!

You need to log in, in order to post comments.

MIT World — special events and lectures

MIT World — special events and lectures

Category: Events | Updated over 2 years ago

December 14, 2011 14:23
All Rights Reserved (What is this?)
Additional Files

9479 times

More from MIT World — special events and lectures

Autism Research: Progress and Promises

Autism Research: Progress and Promises

Added over 6 years ago | 00:43:07 | 10736 views

The OpenCourseWare Initiative: A New Model for Sharing

The OpenCourseWare Initiative: A Ne...

Added over 6 years ago | 00:37:43 | 3454 views

Reflections on the Big Dig

Reflections on the Big Dig

Added over 6 years ago | 00:46:10 | 4943 views

The Last Time I Saw Bali

The Last Time I Saw Bali

Added over 6 years ago | 01:20:00 | 3386 views

Doing R&D Smarter: A More Effective Approach to Industrial R&D

Doing R&D Smarter: A More Effective...

Added over 6 years ago | 01:10:00 | 3488 views

The Road from Copenhagen

The Road from Copenhagen

Added over 6 years ago | 01:54:00 | 20735 views