Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Sign in Create Account

The Future of Digital Commons (MIT Commnications Forum)

09/22/2005 5:00 PM stata
Nancy Kranich, Former President, American Library Association; Guest Lecturer; Ann Wolpert, Director of Libraries; Steven Pinker, Johnstone Family Professor of Psychology; Harvard University;

Nancy Kranich says the debate boils down to this: "Is information a public good or a commodity?" The more profit to be made, the higher the tension. Kranich envisions an "information society of the 21st century," where the ruling metaphor is the commons: information is neither public nor private but something shared. Intellectual assets are not given away but managed "to sustain communities of interest," and to foster free expression, creativity, innovation and democracy.

Ideas, unlike popsicles, do not disappear once they are consumed, Ann Wolpert notes. And the resources of the academic world are intended to be used repeatedly -- exchanged and enhanced. Wolpert finds particularly threatening the notion of extending copyright law to the work of academics. Ideas should not "be stuffed in the same box as Mickey Mouse," she says. The internet has fundamentally changed the flow of information, and while it has encouraged a greater degree of "social sharing," it is now threatened by market forces, which insist on controlling and realizing profit from ideas. Asserts Wolpert, "Neither the academy nor society can tolerate tight control over movement of information. For knowledge to advance, production and distribution systems can and should occur outside the tightly controlled, capital intensive publishing system."

Steven Pinker admits that "as both a consumer and producer of information," he has not resolved the conflicting demands of distributing his research freely, and making a living from it. "There is the question of how many ' books would I write if I didn't get a check in the mail from the publisher every once in while." He warns against designing and promoting an information commons that relies exclusively on generosity, openness and inclusiveness -- human nature being what it is. However, Pinker finds hope in such models as Apple's iTunes, with its micropayments to download music, and Wikipedia the online, participatory encyclopedia where people engage in uncompensated activity for the prestige of making "accurate and useful entries" in a shared online resource.

Host(s): School of Humanities, Arts & Social Sciences, Communications Forum

Tape #: T20268

Comments (0)

It looks like no one has posted a comment yet. You can be the first!

You need to log in, in order to post comments. If you don’t have an account yet, sign up now!

December 12, 2011 20:35
All Rights Reserved (What is this?)
Additional Files

5818 times

More from MIT Communications Forum

Election 2004: Did the Media Fail? (MIT Communications Forum)

Election 2004: Did the Media Fail? ...

Added almost 4 years ago | 01:57:00 | 6463 views

Prime Time in Transition (MIT Communications Forum)

Prime Time in Transition (MIT Commu...

Added almost 4 years ago | 01:49:00 | 4608 views

Born Digital

Born Digital

Added almost 2 years ago | 02:00:49 | 2004 views

Media in Transition 8 - Summing Up, Looking Ahead

Media in Transition 8 - Summing Up,...

Added over 2 years ago | 01:21:10 | 1875 views

Documentary Film and New Technologies (MIT Communications Forum)

Documentary Film and New Technologi...

Added over 3 years ago | 01:57:57 | 8536 views

A Conversation with Nate Silver (MIT Communications Forum)

A Conversation with Nate Silver (MI...

Added over 2 years ago | 01:59:08 | 3165 views