Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Sign in

Iran: War or Peace?

03/20/2007 4:30 PM E51-345
Kenneth Pollack, PhD '96, Director of Research, Saban Center for Middle East Policy and Senior Fellow, Foreign Policy Studies

Description: The Bush administration's panic about failing in Iraq is now driving its fierce attitude toward Iran, according to Kenneth Pollack. President Bush's 2007 State of the Union message hinted at exercising military force to deal with an Iran it accused of stoking up insurgency in Iraq. Pollack points out that historically, this administration tends to point the finger at others when its strategy proves faulty. Not that long ago, the U.S. suggested Saddam Hussein was behind all the Middle East's problems, says Pollack, and then when we removed him, -bizarrely, the problems didn't go away." So now, the U.S. accuses Iran of sending deadly explosive devices into Iraq, killing Americans and obstructing reconstruction efforts there. This -knee-jerk and customary response of saber rattling" is contrary to our best interests not just in Iraq, says Pollack, but in the monumental effort to prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons. There are steps the U.S. must take if it hopes to avoid an even greater Middle Eastern debacle. Pollack suggests a change in tack, and tone, by pursuing rational diplomatic initiatives. The U.S., says Pollack, should ask Iran to use its influence in Iraq to diminish the mayhem there -- and offer the Iranians something in return. Spell out positive goals, and provide incentives, he suggests. And while engaged in a dialogue around Iraq, continue with international allies to apply economic pressure on Iran to abandon its nuclear weapons program. Pollack points out that Iran's economy -continues to do poorly at a time when oil money is flooding its coffers, causing popular unhappiness." If starved of foreign capital, Iran may be forced to choose between an expensive nuclear weapons program and salvaging its economy. When North Korea chose nuclear weapons, three million people starved, recalls Pollack. Iran is unlikely to make the same decision. So -slowly turn up the heat" while offering to help jumpstart a new, high tech-based economy. Most important, Pollack hammers home, is that the Bush administration lose the bellicose rhetoric _ i.e., stop -intoning its mantra of 'all options are on the table.'" Hardliners in Iran welcome the opportunity to cast the U.S. as an unfair bully intent on keeping Iran weak. The administration seems to be looking for ways to rescue its legacy from the debacle of Iraq. Its only hope is by dropping aggressive rhetoric and -rediscovering diplomacy," including the use of rewards and bartering, says Pollack. The administration has not been known for -subtlety and patience," concludes Pollack, so Iran may prove to be the acid test for a genuine attempt at diplomacy.

About the Speaker(s): Kenneth Pollack previously served as Director for National Security Studies at the Council on Foreign Relations; as the Director for Persian Gulf Affairs, National Security Council; the Director for Near East and South Asian Affairs, National Security Council; Senior Research Professor, National Defense University; and an Iran-Iraq Military Analyst for the Central Intelligence Agency.

Pollack received his B.A. from Yale University in 1988 and his Ph.D. from MIT in 1996.

Host(s): Dean for Student Life, Technology and Culture Forum

Comments (0)

It looks like no one has posted a comment yet. You can be the first!

You need to log in, in order to post comments.

MIT World — special events and lectures

MIT World — special events and lectures

Category: Events | Updated 2 years ago

December 13, 2011 19:01
All Rights Reserved (What is this?)
Additional Files

7275 times

More from MIT World — special events and lectures

The Networked World:  Are We Ready For It?

The Networked World: Are We Ready ...

Added almost 6 years ago | 00:27:37 | 3486 views

The Resilient Enterprise:  Overcoming Vulnerability for Competitive Advantage

The Resilient Enterprise: Overcomi...

Added almost 6 years ago | 01:03:00 | 4461 views

Reminiscences of McKinley, the Matterhorn and Everest

Reminiscences of McKinley, the Matt...

Added almost 6 years ago | 01:36:00 | 4998 views

China, Taiwan , and the U.S.: A Coming Conflict? Session Two

China, Taiwan , and the U.S.: A Com...

Added almost 6 years ago | 01:31:00 | 3023 views

Getting Unstuck: How to Promote More Sustainable Practices in Our Organizations

Getting Unstuck: How to Promote Mor...

Added almost 6 years ago | 00:53:51 | 10602 views

What (if Anything) Should Be Done About Improving the System of Electing a President? (Part three)

What (if Anything) Should Be Done A...

Added almost 6 years ago | 01:00:00 | 11479 views